Legacy Fence
(405) 250-5500CallGet My Instant Quote
Fence Advice

Choosing The Right Wood For My Fence Project

Kirby Smith June 01, 2026
Choosing The Right Wood For My Fence Project

There are many different options for lumber so how do you select the right one? Let’s go over the options.

⚡ QUICK SUMMARY

Not all fence lumber is equal. Pressure treated pine twists and warps. Japanese cedar curls and pops off. Untreated pine is okay but short-lived. Western Red Cedar is our most installed wood and the one we recommend.

WE DON'T OFFER IT  Pressure Treated Pine

Pressure treated lumber is not recommended for fence applications. The wood is soaked to the core with chemicals to prevent insect damage, within the first few months the treatment seeps out of the wood causing twisting and warping. This is a low budget option not offered at Legacy Fence and is only designed to last a few years.

Pressure Treated Pine

OK OPTION  Untreated Pine

This is a less costly alternative to western red cedar that we offer. Also referred to as “whitewood” the pine has a cream to yellow color. As the average fence is 200 linear feet the cost difference between pine and cedar is minimal and we always recommend going with western red cedar as the red cedar outlasts the pine by 5 to 10 years.

Untreated Pine

AVOID  Japanese Cedar

This is a newer option to the US market that is slightly cheaper than the western red cedar. The pickets curl on the ends and swell and pop off the fence resulting in callbacks. We discontinued using this product after a 100% callback rate. In this example you can see the morning had perfectly straight pickets and by just that afternoon they were curled up, within a few days we were replacing pickets. We recommend staying away from this product.

Japanese Cedar

100%

callback rate on Japanese cedar pickets

Why we discontinued the product

BEST CHOICE  Western Red Cedar

This is our most installed wood product and highly recommended. Western red cedar contains oils that make it naturally rot and insect resistant and isn’t likely to shrink or warp after installation.

💡 Pro Tip

As the average fence is 200 linear feet, the cost difference between pine and cedar is minimal - and the red cedar outlasts the pine by 5 to 10 years. That's why we always recommend Western Red Cedar.

Want a Western Red Cedar Fence Built Right?

Get a free, no-obligation quote from Legacy Fence. Serving the Oklahoma City metro since 2007.

Get My Free Quote →

Or call or text us: (405) 250-5500

Let’s Build the Fence Your Neighbors Wish They Had.

Tell us a little about your project, and the Legacy Fence team will be in touch to discuss the details.

CallTextFree Quote